3D printing – Outsource, or print in-house?

3D printing – Outsource, or print in-house?

  • Applications

3D printing is becoming increasingly integral in the workplace. It helps companies validate designs, perform functional tests, and bring products to market more quickly. 3D printed prototypes are useful for communicating concepts with stakeholders, resulting in faster iterations and better quality products. Executives seldom need to be convinced of the benefits – yet many continue to outsource their 3D printing tasks; especially when it comes to final part production.

Why companies outsource

Outsourcing means no investment in machinery or training. It also eliminates uncertainty about in-house manufacturing of functional prototypes or final parts. SMEs can’t afford expensive industrial additive manufacturing equipment – outsourcing gives them access to this, and to the right level of expertise, which improves their pipeline efficiency. Even engineering teams in large enterprises haven’t always got the budget to invest in expensive training and equipment.

An alternative solution

Models and prototypes are crucial at the design stage, and companies want quicker, more effective ways to develop their product concepts. Outsourcing lets them use 3D printing technology without a large initial investment; but the throughput times can still be significant, undercutting the short iterations usually associated with 3D printing.

Desktop 3D printers offer a great alternative, without requiring a significant financial investment. They deliver professional results and other benefits; lower costs, quicker lead times, more customer interactions and higher scalability. They’re also easy to operate, resulting in more capacity, more teams, and more departments making use of them. In short, they make 3D printing accessible to more professional users, regardless of industry.

What are your options?

This depends both on purpose and application. Businesses have three options when it comes to 3D printing: outsource the tasks, print in-house with industrial machines, or invest in cost-effective, accessible desktop 3D printers.

The following sections examine the pros and cons of each.

3D printed tools
A collection of tools 3D printed in-house and outsourced

Outsourcing to third parties

Outsourcing is a good option if you’re looking for exceptional quality, low quantities, and high complexity. It’s the right choice if you need five parts or fewer per month, especially if the parts are large or require non-standard materials. It’s also useful for final parts that require unusual materials or applications.

However, be warned – this is the slowest, priciest option. Yes, you’ll have an expert performing the task without the associated risks of long-term commitment. But the hourly or project rate is often substantially higher than hiring an employee, and you’ll be waiting longer for them to complete the job.

Pros:

  • Several technologies available in-house, such as SLA, FFF, and SLS

  • More materials than an in-house system

  • Expert knowledge about materials (and their limitations)

  • No long-term commitment

  • No initial investment

Cons:

  • Cost per part is far higher than in-house printing

  • Slower process - weeks instead of days

  • More paperwork and more workflow steps. You’ll need to contact suppliers, review quotes, put in a purchase request, pass over specifications, develop ideas, evaluate functionality, and more

  • Small amendments are expensive

  • Multiple iterations take longer to create

  • Customer locked in with software, add-ons, or filaments

  • Structural underutilization

  • Inaccessibility. An operator is needed, engineers can’t use it directly, and maintenance means no availability

  • Not scalable

Industrial 3D printer
Parts inside the build chamber of a large industrial 3D printer

In-house industrial 3D printers

Industrial printers are ideal if you’re producing large batches of parts. You’ll need to use the printers frequently to justify the considerable investment and training involved.

Pros:

  • Wide range of high-performance materials available

  • When implemented, it’s quicker than using third-party service bureaus

  • Cost-effective option (when printing in large batches)

Cons:

  • Significant up-front investment. Expect to pay between $250,000 and $1 million for a comprehensive manufacturing system

  • Lots of space required. True manufacturing systems require over 30m2 of floor space, industrial HVAC, finishing stations, cleaning stations, and more

  • Accounting for all costs, a single build would cost more than a desktop 3D printer (approximately $3,000, plus usage and labor)

  • Unsuitable for short batches – costs a lot more per printed product

ultimaker vw stills 00067
Desktop 3D printers provide a cost-effective and versatile solution

In-house desktop 3D printers

Desktop 3D printers are perfect for rapid prototyping. If you’re doing a lot of printing, a print farm of multiple desktop machines is far cheaper and easier-to-scale than industrial printing. Multiple printers and 3D print clusters also offer more flexibility and control (e.g. printing one part per machine).

Pros:

  • Most cost-effective option. An outsourced prototype can cost thousands of dollars (for complex models). On average, printing in-house costs a tenth of the price

  • Quicker turnaround time. Outsourcing 3D printed parts takes about a week. An in-house 3D printer produces a prototype in a matter of hours, shaving weeks off the development cycle. Products can be brought to market in a fraction of the time

  • Greater flexibility – tweak designs at a far lower cost

  • No risk of designs being leaked – it’s all done in the safety of your business premises

  • Total design control – print fine details, smooth surfaces, and even moving parts in a single build

  • Less room required

  • Relatively inexpensive and scalable

Cons:

  • Most desktop 3D printers are technically limited to printing high-performance materials

  • More suited for smaller-size parts

  • Not as suitable for mass customization

  • Employee training is required (but less intense and complicated compared to industrial machines)

Questions to ask

Before committing to a 3D printing solution, ask yourself the following:

  • What do you need the parts for? Functional prototyping? Visual display? Casting into end products?

  • What materials will you be using?

  • How many parts will you need per week? How many parts can you fit into one build volume on a desktop, or on an industrial machine?

  • How familiar are your employees with additive manufacturing processes? Is additional training required?

  • What is the timeline for implementing 3D printing into your workflow?

  • What best suits your working environment?

In most cases, investing in several in-house desktop printers is the best option, then outsourcing final parts with specific requirements to a service bureau. It’s the cost-effective choice, not only for knowledge workers and design or engineering teams, but also for multinational companies. Industrial machines are often underutilized and not worth the investment, unless your business model involves mass customization or low-volume, high-profit activities. If you’re confident that you’ll need large batches of parts with high compliance (e.g. aerospace), then this may be a viable option for you.

Consider not only your current requirements as a company, but what you’re looking to achieve in the future. Cost and practicality should always be a priority, but so too should scalability and creative potential.

Explore more 3D printing knowledge

Read more blogs

  • 3d-printing-materials

    3D printing materials: What you should know first

    In part one of our three-part series on 3D printing materials, dive into FFF 3D printing, get an overview of Ultimaker's material range, and learn about the importance of an open-filament system.

    Ultimaker-S5-material-station

    Which Ultimaker S5 Material Station setup is right for you?

    The release of the Ultimaker S5 Material Station opens the door for a wide range of use cases. But how best to configure the materials contained within it?

    2019-in-review-og

    3D printing in 2019: Ultimaker's year in review

    From innovative new products to inspiring success stories, 2019 has been an eventful and exciting year for 3D printing. Here's a look back at a few of the highlights.

  • material-wall-1

    Improving industrial applications with the Ultimaker Material Alliance

    Partners of the Ultimaker Material Alliance are doing their part at furthering the 3D printing industry, from UL Blue Card-certification to ESD-safe material to metal-polymer composites.

    Making it work: 3D printing and engineering

    Making it work: 3D printing and engineering

    From rapid prototypes to end-use parts, 3D printing is a perfect addition to an engineer's workflow, in which wasted time is wasted money.

    ultimaker-roi-calculator

    3D printing and ROI: Build your business case

    Bringing 3D printing into your business is cost-efficient, convenient, and transformative. But it's important to understand and calculate your return on investment from the technology.

  • Ultimaker Cura 4.4 og image

    Achieve success faster with Ultimaker Cura 4.4

    Intent profiles in Ultimaker Cura simplify 3D printing. Just load your CAD data, choose a profile that matches your print’s intent, and hit print.

    Ultimaker 3D Printing Sentiment Index 2019

    3D Printing Sentiment Index: Which countries lead the way?

    Where is the biggest 3D printing growth potential in 2019? This blog reveals the results and methodology behind Ultimaker's first global 3D Printing Sentiment Index.

    Ultimaker LEHVOSS Group

    Ultimaker and LEHVOSS Group: Scaling industrial applications for 3D printing

    A partnership between Ultimaker and LEHVOSS Group is the beginning of a new level of 3D printing, lowering the barrier for industrial adoption.

  • hero-og

    Discover Intent profiles in Ultimaker Cura 4.4 beta

    Intent profiles in Ultimaker Cura simplify 3D printing preparation, give you results that match your intent, and maximize your print success rate, so you can show the true value of 3D printing in your business.

    The Ultimaker Material Alliance: Pushing boundaries at K 2019

    The Ultimaker Material Alliance: Pushing boundaries at K 2019

    The impact of the Ultimaker Material Alliance was evident at K 2019, the world’s premier trade fair for plastics and rubber.

    6 factors that affect indoor air quality when 3D printing OG

    6 key factors that affect indoor air quality when 3D printing

    Concerned about air quality and 3D printer particle emissions? Check out this blog to learn the 6 factors that affect your indoor air quality when 3D printing.

  • Glass vs carbon fiber composite 3D printing materials

    Glass vs. carbon fiber 3D printing composites

    It's a common question. Which composite material is right for your 3D printing application? Carbon fiber or fiberglass? Check out this in-depth blog!

    marketplace-1m-og

    Ultimaker Marketplace hits 1 million downloads

    The Ultimaker Marketplace, our digital distribution platform, has just hit a major milestone of 1 million downloads for plugins and print profiles combined. Ultimaker now has the largest compatible material choice in the entire 3D printing market.

    TCT Show OG

    A visual recap of TCT Show 2019

    Big crowds, big announcements, and more – get the full photographic rundown of 2019's TCT Show.

  • og-image

    Ultimaker Cura 4.3: Available now

    We've released a new upgrade of our print preparation software. Join millions of users worldwide and benefit from an advanced slicing engine that offers integration with the Ultimaker Marketplace, and a cloud-connected workflow for ultimate flexibility. Don’t miss out! Update today.

    Introducing the new Ultimaker S5 Pro Bundle OG image

    Meet the Ultimaker S5 Pro Bundle

    24/7 automated material handling, air filtration, filament humidity control. Find out how our unique 3D printing solution unlocks more demanding applications.

    Introducing Ultimaker S3 the newest addition to our S-line of 3D printers OG

    Ultimaker S3 – the newest addition to our S-line of 3D printers

    Composite-ready, dual extrusion, auto bed leveling, touchscreen. Learn how Ultimaker S3 delivers robust desktop 3D printing so you can start innovating faster.

  • Owens Corning talks 3D printing

    An industrial adoption: Owens Corning talks 3D printing

    Composite materials powerhouse Owens Corning explains why and how 3D printing can transform workflows

    cura-43-beta

    6 things you can try today in Ultimaker Cura 4.3 beta

    From more 3D file formats to an easy selector for Z seam positions, here are six great features of Ultimaker Cura 4.3 beta

    3d-printing-and-automotive-industry

    In the driver’s seat: 3D printing and the automotive industry

    Designing and creating a vehicle is hard work – but 3D printing can lighten the load

  • lean-principles-og-image

    5 lean manufacturing principles demonstrated by 3D printing

    Explore the the 5 principles of lean manufacturing and how leading brands have implemented them thanks to Ultimaker 3D printers.

    Ultimaker-Cloud-Teams-blog-hero-2

    Ultimaker Cloud: Achieve more together using Teams

    With Ultimaker Cloud's latest feature, Teams, you can connect and collaborate with colleagues and control multiple groups of Ultimaker 3D printers.

    3d printing for molds

    A perfect fit: 3D printing for molds and casting

    How is additive manufacturing changing the creation of molds and casts? From silicone molds to investment casting metal, check out this blog for inspiration.

  • An Ultimaker printer prints a L’Oréal prototype

    Transformative beauty: L’Oréal prepares for the future with 3D printing

    If it’s happening in Ultimaker’s world, you can find out about it here. 3D printing stories about inspiring moments, original 3D printed projects and much much more.

    hero-user-context

    Ultimaker Cura 4.2: First choice for 3D printing professionals worldwide

    Today, the latest version of our powerful, easy-to-use 3D print preparation software is available for download. In this release, we’ve focused on usability improvements that simplify 3D printing workflows, whatever your 3D printing application.

    Ford-hero-blog

    'Beyond the basement': 3D printing in the age of Industry 4.0

    The rise of 3D printing means the technology is more accessible than ever, paving the way for creation, iteration, and innovation

  • Het Noordgebouw

    Onward and upward: New city, new office, new look

    If it’s happening in Ultimaker’s world, you can find out about it here. 3D printing stories about inspiring moments, original 3D printed projects and much much more.

    Ultimaker manufacturing

    Behind the scenes: How Ultimaker 3D printers are manufactured

    If it’s happening in Ultimaker’s world, you can find out about it here. 3D printing stories about inspiring moments, original 3D printed projects and much much more.

    Upgrade your Cura experience with and Ultimaker 3D printer

    Upgrade your Ultimaker Cura experience – with an Ultimaker 3D printer

    If you use Ultimaker Cura, but don't send your print to an Ultimaker 3D printer, then you’re missing out on a ton of functionality...

  • Ultimaker Marketplace

    Accelerate 3D printing productivity with the Ultimaker Marketplace

    If it’s happening in Ultimaker’s world, you can find out about it here. 3D printing stories about inspiring moments, original 3D printed projects and much much more.

    Firmware 5.2

    Activate Ultimaker Cloud with firmware 5.2

    Enjoy all the benefits of Ultimaker Cloud by updating your Ultimaker 3D printers to firmware 5.2. Cloud connectivity and new performance optimizations give you the most powerful 3D printing experience available.

    Ultimaker Cura 4.0

    Simplify 3D printing with Ultimaker Cura 4.0

    Download Ultimaker Cura 4.0 today and enjoy a brand-new user interface designed to simplify 3D print preparation – whether you’re a beginner or an expert. This release adds integration with Ultimaker Cloud, offering you advanced cloud-based tools to support

  • Ultimaker wins prestigious iF Design Award

    Ultimaker wins prestigious iF Design Award

    Ultimaker has been awarded a prestigious iF Design Award for the user interface of our Ultimaker S5 3D printer.

    Ultimaker Cloud

    Introducing Ultimaker Cloud – the next generation 3D printing workflow

    If it’s happening in Ultimaker’s world, you can find out about it here. 3D printing stories about inspiring moments, original 3D printed projects and much much more.

    Application focus: Jigs and fixtures

    Application focus: Jigs and fixtures

    3D Printed jigs and fixtures enable businesses to work faster, save money and add flexibility.